ACT I
- I’ve Got the World on a String – Sinatra (Voice Only)
- Welcome to the Copa! – Frank Sinatra & Ensemble
- Stick With Me, Kid – DiMaggio & Billy
- The Man I Dream About – Nancy Sinatra, Frank, Mickey, Copa Crowd
- Behind the Curtain – Marilyn Monroe
- The Boys of the Bronx – Sinatra & Ensemble or The Boys of the Bronx alternate Version
- Share the Wealth – Uncle Frank, Matty the Horse, Wise Guy Quartet Share the Wealth Alternate Version
- The Look That Struck Out Mickey – Marilyn & Mickey
- The Silence in the Smoke – Instrumental Theme
- Room Service Joe – DiMaggio
- The Last Show – Sammy Davis Jr.
- Trade Him to Kansas City – Topping & Weiss
- Diamonds Don’t Shine in the Dark – Marilyn
- City of Glass – Full Cast
- Welcome to the Copa (Smoke & Satin Version) – A seductive reimagining of the show’s signature number
ACT II
16. The Boy She Believed in – Frank Sinatra
17. Boys Will Be Bombers – Mantle, Martin, Ensemble
18. Pinstripes and Paper Tigers – Weiss, Topping, Reporters, Ensemble
19. Stay Away from the Copa – Topping & Weiss
20. Six Wives and a Pennant – Topping, Weiss, Ensemble
21. Hayseed in Manhattan – Mickey Mantle
22. Kings of the Night – Mickey & Billy
23. Pinstripes & Punchlines – Casey Stengel, Ensemble
24. Mob Rules – The Fixer, Sparatore, Ensemble
25. Back to the Copa! – (Reprise), Back to the Copa! Alternate Version
26. Every Eye in the Room – Marilyn, Holly Brooke, Ensemble. Every Eye in the Room Alternate Version
27. If I Ruled the World – Sammy Davis Jr.
28. Kings of the Night (Reprise) – Mickey & Billy
29. The Man I Married – Ava Gardner
30. The Woman They Want – Marilyn & Ava
31. Two Goddesses, One Mirror – Ava & Marilyn
32. Two Goddesses (Reprise) – Ava & Marilyn
33. Where Have You Gone? (Solo Version) – DiMaggio
ACT III
34. The Year of the Mick – Mickey Mantle, Ensemble
35. You Don’t Have to Cheer – Marilyn Monroe
36. Exiled in Kansas City – Billy Martin, Minor League Ensemble
37. The Ghost of Joe DiMaggio – DiMaggio (offstage or spotlighted)
38. The Five Families Want In – Sparatore, Uncle Frank, The Fixer, Ensemble
39. My Name is Ted F***ing Williams – Ted Williams
40. Where Have You Gone? (Reprise) – Ensemble
41. Coda for a Dead King – Instrumental
42. Death on 60th Street – Ensemble
43. Blood on the Curb – Ensemble
44. The Woman in the Mirror – Marilyn
45. Marilyn Without Monroe – Marilyn & Holly Brooke
46. What Comes Next? – Ensemble
47. Unforgettable – Nat King Cole (Voice Only)
48. Just Say Paris – Marilyn & Mickey
49. City That Never Sleeps – Full Company (Finale Medley)
50. When Mickey Played the City – Sinatra
